Tory modernisation has failed – what now?

By Emma.

It’s only one poll, but it’s pretty conclusive. The work of the Cameron project to modernise the image of the Tory Party has failed. Who says so? ConservativeHome, that’s who.

The public still think the Tories want to cut services for the poor and taxes for the rich. And they do not trust them with the NHS one bit. They think Tories are tough on welfare and immigration. They have all the same attributes from the public – for good or for bad – that they had before they elected Cameron leader in 2005 to change their image. The tree scribble, the huskies, the hoodie-hugging – none of it has made a blind bit of difference compared to the Tories behaviour in government and the implacable sense the voters have of who they are and what they are for.

This graph from Political Betting could have been about the Tory image at any time since the Thatcher revolution.

Of course, despite all this, the Tories did almost, sort of, win the last election. Or at least they were the party that least lost it. But their failure to modernise and become a party that voters view differently is – at least in part – hardened as a result of their behaviour in government contrasted with their promises in opposition. Equally, as Tim Montgomerie points out in the Times(£) the Lib Dems have been allowed to propigate the narrative that they are the restraining force on the Tories, and anything good that comes from the government (what little there is) comes from them.

While the public are still willing to believe that a certain amount of pain is required to get the country back on track (and whether they are right or not, they do still believe this) this is not such a worry for the Conservatives. It is clear that their strategy has been to present themselves as the Party that is soberly able to manage the economy by administering the nasty medicine – hence Cameron’s soporific conference speech. But this would be very poor strategy from them.

If they continue to accept that they are only there to be the nasty medicine, then when voters feel better they will turn away from the Tories once again. If so the best they can hope for is long periods of Labour governments punctuated by brief periods where voters remind themselves of all the things they never liked about the Tories in the first place.

So the Tories either have to actually change – rather than indulge in superficial stunts – or convince voters longer term that nasty is what they want.

As someone who is finding the nastiness of the Tories heartbreaking to the community I live in, while they remain in Government I hope they can change. I have to as that is what would hurt the least people. But I strongly doubt they are capable of doing so. And I am seriously unconvinced they can convince the voters that the only way is nasty for a moment longer than they feel strictly necessary.

Economic recovery is essential to the health of our nation. Labour should greet good economic news with cheer. But we must also keep pushing the message of a recovery for all. But economic recovery is a double edged sword for the Tories. Especially the recovery for the rich they are presiding over, where living standards for all but a very privileged and untouched few continue to fall. If Labour can make the election about cost of living – and they are showing every sign of managing to do so thus far – while the Tories trumpet a recovery that is not reaching most parts of society, that could make their “nasty party” credentials worse, not better.


Tags: ,

2 comments to “Tory modernisation has failed – what now?”

  1. Comment by some solidarity please:

    Come on Emma – as the disgusting spectacle of the poorest most vulnerable people driven from their homes snowballs, the nation will start to look at itself, though before they get too introspective they will have to witness the collapse of the nhs. As society implodes around them the fascist regime will stifle dissent. But then this government is fantastically weak, already on 42 u turns. It wont take much to break these people, however the social devastation will take thirty years to heal. The class war will take up a new dynamic in October, with hospital closures, street lamp switching off, no guards on trains, fire station closures, vast police changes, and massive universal (credit) chaos, against a landscape of fracking in the tory heartlands. This is the twelve months now of breaking Britain. But I shout “Bring it on. Bring it on you bunch of *************”. But this government are ready for massive dissent. That’s why for two years they have been training paratroopers in riot control at Lydd. An important measure also is their Anti-Social, Crime and Policing Bill. This is already at the committee stage and will stop legal protests.

    Miliband has been so incredibly inept, and has sold out ordinary people, of which Rachel Reeves is following a tradition – if you thought Byrne, Balls and Crudas were poor. Labour have proved again they are unfit to govern. Instead Miliband has opened the way for complete division, by Serwotka, Crow and McCluskey. Unions will field radical anti austerity candidates against Labour. As the war on the poor intensifies Scotland will gain independence, further decimating Labour. Miliband needs to wake up to this being a true crisis. A movement of the people will now destroy Labour. The Discretionary Housing Benefit will stop soon and the first 200000 vulnerable disabled people will be evicted. They will be homeless, but they are just the first wave.

    When the people are evicted they will go to the nhs to die. The NHS will collapse, but it will make 4 million old people vulnerable. Time has now run out, Emma, the class war is now on. You will have to watch in horror as these people die very very slowly in the freezing winter of 2014.

  2. Comment by Emma:

    There are a great many predictions here about what is going to happen over the next 12 – 18 months. As I did with my own predictions for 2011 I look forward to revisiting this post after the 2015 election to see how much was right and wrong.

Leave a Reply



© All content is the copyright of Emma Burnell but I give permission for its use as long as it is properly credited, unless otherwise stated.
The views stated are those of Emma Burnell and the other occassional contributors.
They are not the views of any employer or organisation with which these individuals are involved.
Scarlet Standard | RSS Feed | WordPress | Redtopia by Jeremy Clark | Top
57 mySQL queries executed in 0.442 seconds.